I played poker Monday night. There was a not so common hand that had 4 players after the flop, player 1, 2, 3, and 4. If I can remember it right, player 1 was the first to act. Eventually, player 2 bet out of turn and then went all in and so then moved his chips into the pot without hesitations. Player 1 then followed player 2 and so also went all in and then moved his chips of course into the pot.

Eventually, two players have acted out of turn as the action should have been to player C with the hand of player 2 intended to be checked.

Our rules went as follows:

1. Player 2 acted out of turn.
2. Then there was still an action right after his bet although player 1 now acted out of turn.
3. The bet of player 2 was binding due to player 1′s action.
4. Because of the incident, players 3 and 4 can play their hand.

What’s your thoughts?

Thanks!

Regards,
Browner
Browner,

This is how it should have went.

1. Player 2 acted out of turn. Player receives a warning for acting out of turn.
   
2. Player 1 has an option to either check or bet. If the player checks, then player 2’s bet is binding. If player 1 bets, then player 2 has the option of taking his bet back and acting accordingly.
   
3. When player 1 bet, player 2 had the option of taking his bet back and folding, calling the all-in of player 1, or reraising if he had more chips.
   
4. Play continues as normal to player 3 and 4.